No one cares that much now but watch out if they continue to bring in more talent. Sure Ridley has had International students for as long as I can remember but the focus has now shifted to actively searching out ones who are skilled at sports.
Outside of Rowing, it seems Ridley's focus on sports was in more of an extrcurricullar type of emphasis until lately.
In order to continue to bring in students the admin has realised the importance of having excellent sports teams ( a correct decision ) and they have vast resources to do so. I believe they have a recruiting budget and coaches are encouraged and instructed to search out players.
This comes right from the coaches mouth ("we recruited him out of the Bahamas "

and is not hearsay. Sure other schools have recruited certain players from the Niagara Region in the past but to compare the two situations is a little naive I think.
Again, there is nothing unethical going on here , the issue becomes a level playing field. Other private institutions do the same thing and they should most likely play each other exclusively outside of some exhibition play if public schools choose to do so.